Will France choose in or out of the U.S. Area Command’s Operation Olympic Defender?

On April 9, 2024, U.S. Area Power Gen. Stephen Whiting introduced that the U.S. Area Command has invited France, Germany and New Zealand to affix Operation Olympic Defender. On Could 14, France’s head of house operations commented that, whereas the French authorities has not but reached a choice, the invitation itself gives a “message of strategic solidarity.” France has confirmed to be not solely an abiding however an advancing pressure within the realm of house, particularly militarily. When — or if — France decides to provide a agency response to this invitation, it can drive the close to way forward for house alliances for each the U.S. and China.

The U.S.-led Operation Olympic Defender (OOD), initially fashioned by the U.S. navy in 2013 to guard satellites in house, developed in 2018 into a global effort between the closest allies of the U.S. “to discourage hostile actions in house.” Formally transferred to the U.S. Area Command (USSC) in Could 2020 — six months after the institution of the U.S. Area Power (USSF) — its mission stays largely centered on intelligence-sharing and exchanges of personnel, being described by the us as “a multinational effort meant to optimize house operations, enhance mission assurance, improve resilience, and synchronize efforts.”

At present, the OOD membership roster holds 5 names: the U.S., the UK, Canada and Australia — 4 of the 5 members of the 5 Eyes intelligence alliance — with the fifth and ultimate OOD member being New Zealand. 

The timing of this invitation to France is unsurprising. Starting March 20, the governments of the U.S. and France held the second assembly of the U.S.-France Complete Dialogue on Area, which was rapidly adopted by the discharge of a joint assertion. This assertion lists an array of ongoing points in house, together with safety, scientific and lunar exploration, worldwide house legislation, local weather science and personal sector involvement. Whereas no different nation — resembling China or Russia — is known as on this official assertion, its language delivers a way of ever-growing urgency to behave in opposition to “the total spectrum of hazards and threats.”

France (like a lot of Europe) can also be in a interval of renewed vigor to stay related and influential in house operations. In December 2023, French President Emmanuel Macron introduced the brand new “France 2030” nationwide funding plan, with the ninth of the plan’s 10 Targets being to “take full half within the new house journey.” In his messaging, Macron affirmed that France “should interact on this competitors … paving the best way for personal initiatives and inspiring extra danger taking.” France’s subsequent presidential election isn’t set to be held till 2027, leaving Macron the possibility to put the robust basis for France 2030’s 10 Targets and, thus, stay influential in house; a probably distinctive affect given France’s relations with the U.S. and China.

Even with out this recent funding, France has lengthy confirmed to be a sturdy participant in house, very true because it pertains to the combination of navy forces in house. France’s Joint Area Command, initially fashioned in 2010, was outdated by the French Area Command in September 2019, with its Air Power being renamed because the French Air and Area Power one 12 months later. Then, in March 2021, France led its first multinational navy house train alongside the U.S., Germany and Italy, additional arguing that France has ambitions to change into a pacesetter — not only a follower — in house operations. Notably, France has additionally recurrently partnered with China on satellites ever since signing a bilateral settlement in Could 1997, additional selling its versatility in each data and partnerships relating to house.

Moreover, each France and Germany have been invited to affix the operation earlier than, in 2021. As OOD is primarily an intelligence-sharing cooperative, any invitation given should be totally vetted and deliberately provided. On the components of France and Germany, which means their participation has lengthy been thought-about and twice-vetted, additional encouraging stronger bilateral relations and goodwill between the 2 international locations typically. Extra importantly, France is already collaborating on house with most of those OOD-associated international locations within the Mixed Area Operations Initiative, which was arrange in 2014 and launched its Imaginative and prescient 2031 in February 2022.

With these factors in thoughts, it’s unsurprising why the U.S. wouldn’t solely lengthen such a suggestion of partnership to France but additionally endeavor for the provide to ultimately be accepted. On April 18, USSF Gen. Whiting, head of the us, hosted a multinational assembly with representatives of seven different nations — the 4 present members and France, Germany and New Zealand, the three OOD invitees — in Colorado Springs, Colorado, particularly to additional focus on OOD.

Nonetheless, whether or not or not France will settle for this renewed provide stays unclear. 

Even inside the final six months, a number of unnerving shifts have taken place relating to house relations that should be accounted for, particularly inside the U.S. context. As an example, it’s evident by leaders’ rhetoric, official technique releases and joint releases recurrently produced during the last half 12 months that the us is fixated on getting ready for extreme battle in order to defend the U.S., its allies, and their mutual pursuits. USSF Chief of Area Operations Basic Likelihood Salzman summarized the U.S. goal on the Mitchell Institute’s third Annual Spacepower Safety Discussion board in Arlington on March 27: “We should shield our house capabilities whereas with the ability to deny an adversary the hostile use of its house capabilities … As a result of if we would not have house, we lose.”

Joint collaboration continues to be a prevalent matter for U.S. leaders, however solely in reference to a choose group of long-trusted events. A line has been drawn — and is turning into deeper with each official assertion — on a area that assumes the longer term holds nothing however conflict in house and does little however assures the institution of an us-versus-them mentality. This educated and blatantly marketed assumption of conflict, whereas viably comprehensible after many years of intelligence evaluation and coverage prioritization, concurrently imposes limitations in a future filled with unknowns the place choices are immeasurably helpful. 

With this undeniably aggressive narrative, coupled with years of delays in U.S. house packages, it’s no surprise that France is taking its time to reply whether or not or to not tie themselves to this narrative. France’s two many years of collaboration with China — freshly strengthened throughout a go to by President Xi Jinping to France in Could — could also be what retains France from totally accepting the U.S.’s provide to affix OOD.

Maybe France will repeat its pattern from 2021 and maintain its standing on the OOD roster unchanged. Maybe France will determine to obviously state its place in a present of coverage prioritization and alliance constructing. Maybe France will acknowledge its distinctive placement as a mutual bilateral accomplice of each the U.S. and China in house and make the most of that to assist stabilize U.S.-China relations on house points for the betterment of all events. Or, maybe France will drag out its ultimate determination to see the place the subsequent six months of this rapidly-changing area lead.

Regardless, circumstances have drastically modified within the final three years, and France should undoubtedly incorporate these adjustments into its calculations. With the us now totally operational, North Korea’s and Russia’s nuclear risk ranges escalating, France’s renewed investments and France’s recent pair of agreements on house collaboration with the U.S. and China, there may be bountiful purpose for France to laboriously debate its OOD membership. On this renewed house race that’s simply now choosing up velocity, and with France’s clear dedication to and expertise within the area, any open declaration on house collaboration by France, not to mention a choice relating to the U.S.’s selective OOD membership, can be a significant win — or setback — for the U.S. in its battle for house domination in opposition to its self-declared rivals China and Russia.

Jessica Martin is a Analysis Affiliate and Supervisor of the Maritime Affairs Program on the Institute for China-America Research in Washington, D.C.

Associated